Strahl Lake Autumn

Another version of one I poster earlier but took down to rework.

Nice

Good Phil but again too much crap in the water...

@inkslinger. the "Crap" in the water is nature. I really can't do anything about that. It's autumn and you are going to see things like leaves and moss in the water. I don't see how naturally occurring nature is a reason for a 3 point deduction.

Look my man you are just gonna have to clean up that lake!!!!!

I think it would be disrespectful to other posts to give this image a higher score, its good but not great or even suoerb. Good = 7...

Wonderful Shot!

it's a 7 because of nature... ok can't fight that logic.

9

process is much better 9

Phil, not very respectful to make childish comments on other members posts with reference to your post....

i like it Phil,, I will crop out 3 cms ( bottom part). but its a great image. calm and quiet. leaves on lake are part of the beauty for me..

@Carlos, thanks for the comment. Nice suggestion about the crop

agree about the crop

I think is a bit off, the elements on the water look good to me as it's nature.

9

Totally agree with Mario.

9

Agree on crop as well. Download looks a lot like a Topaz Process...Very Painterly, Like a Monet Painting....8+ IMHO.

I know its nature Phil but…would I advertise this lake. NO!!! It's like some waterways we get in England full of crap, green algae & the odd shopping trolley/stolen car etc... Would I photograph this… NO…Would I publish this NO…. The other day you receive

you received the same comment from another member reference cleaning up the water of leaves & logs etc…All I am doing is being respectful to other members & their images in my voting... This is nowhere near the quality of James's (10) image today, not as

clean & as well processed as Ricardo's (9) or most of the other images today either. So shall I disrespect their images & give you 10 or 9 also…NO…My choice was 8 = Great or 7 = Good… You had already deleted 1 image prior to this today Phil, because of ne

negative feedback, something else you do quite often because of the negative response. I sent you a PM the other day (Monday) suggesting you don’t rush your postings & that you don’t have to post every single day…..but today you PM me & accuse me of havin

having a problem with ‘YOU’…..’I HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH YOU’…Its your images you are posting, if you post your image on here ‘Hdrcreme’ then accept the comments, votes etc….Don’t throw your toys out of the pram. It seems (to you) that I only pick on your i

images but in reality you’re the only one who reacts in this manner … Getting back to your image: ‘Spot Metering’, f9 & ISO 200 I feel is not good for this type of landscape, the image is blurred (with exception on the crap/algae in the water) the trees h

have quite a bit of C/A on the tree tops... If my memory serves me well your images this week 5/7 including the deleted ones & only 1 has got into the top 10, I will stand to be corrected on that Phil but I haven’t voted on any of them since Sunday as I h

have been very busy. Now doesn’t that say something…..it’s not down to my scoring or my 7 today……. I also dislike the way other members pick up your toys & give them back & say ‘Never Mind Phil it will be ok’….It’s not what Hdrcreme is all about….

P.S. You can read this fully on a blog I have just posted on the Forum....Respect to ALL MEMBERS.....

ok so you said all that. Great. BUT your original reason for the 7 was the "too much Crap in the water" But now you are saying it's all of these other things. And no one else said anythng else about the stuff in the water except billyspad. I hope you f

feel better that you have gotten that off of your chest.

You are your own worst enemy Phil....

Sorry Phil, agree with above